Barrels of apple-y goodness... fresh picked for your gaming delight!

 

last update: November 20, 2004

Wonderful Mechanics

These categories are for the best games using a particular game mechanic.

Action Games

  • Bamboleo
  • Bandu/Bausack
  • Cairo
  • Elchfest
  • Kapitän Wackelpudding
  • Piratenbillards
  • Tennis Masters
  • Villa Paletti

Auction Games

  • For Sale
  • High Society
  • Medici
  • Modern Art
  • Ra
  • Traumfabrik

  • Das Amulett
  • Marracash
  • Merchants of Amsterdam
  • Pizarro & Co.

Dice Games

  • Buttonmen
  • Can't Stop
  • Liar's Dice/Bluff/Call My Bluff
  • Yahtzee/Triple Yahtzee

  • Bongo
  • Cosmic Wimpout
  • Elfenwizards
  • Exxtra
  • Fill or Bust
  • Gold Connection
  • Knights/Knatsch
  • Last Chance/Gambler (in Germany)
  • Pass the Pigs/Pigmania

Negotiation Games (Trading)

  • Civilization/Advanced Civilization
  • Klunker [gcs]
  • Kuhhandel
  • Nicht die Bohne
  • Res Publica
  • Starfarers of Catan

Negotiation Games (Non-Trading)

  • Cosmic Encounter
  • Diplomacy
  • Kohle, Kies, & Knete
  • Rette Sich wer Kann
  • Traders of Genoa

  • Metropolis
  • Quo Vadis?
  • Die Händler
  • Dragon's Gold
  • Europa 1945-2030
  • Intrige
  • Junta

Party/Social Games

  • Apples to Apples
  • Balderdash/Beyond Balderdash
  • Taboo
  • Take It Easy
  • Time's Up

  • 25 Words or Less
  • Barbarossa
  • Once Upon a Time
  • Pass the Bomb
  • Password
  • Pictionary
  • Plem Plem
  • Scattergories
  • Werewolf

Trick-Taking Card Games

  • Mü und Mehr
  • Schnäppchen Jagd
  • Sticheln
  • Tichu
  • Where's Bob's Hat?/Wer hat mehr
  • Wizard

  • Dia de los Muertos
  • David & Goliath
  • Frank's Zoo
  • Twilight/Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde
  • Was Sticht?

Word Games

  • Apples to Apples
  • Boggle/Big Boggle
  • Password
  • Scrabble
  • Taboo

  • Balderdash/Beyond Balderdash
  • Montage
  • My Word!
  • Pass the Bomb
  • Pick Two
  • Scattergories
  • Upwords

Good Times, Good Friends

These categories are for the best games categorized by their length or number of players.

Filler Games (15-30 minutes)

  • Can't Stop
  • High Society
  • Liar's Dice/Bluff/Call My Bluff
  • Schnäppchen Jagd
  • Take 6/6 Nimmt
  • Transamerica

  • Honeybears
  • Quandry/Flinke Pinke
  • Web of Power/Kardinal und König
  • Apples to Apples
  • Kupferkessel Co.
  • Ra
  • Ricochet Robot
  • Wyatt Earp

Filler Games (15 minutes or less)

  • Bongo
  • Button Men
  • Elchfest
  • Pico/Pico 2
  • Spinball
  • Wurmeln

"Long" Games

  • 18xx
  • Civilization/Advanced Civilization
  • Die Macher
  • Funkenschlag
  • La Citta

  • History of the World
  • Diplomacy
  • Junta
  • Pampas Railroads
  • Roads & Boats
  • Serenissima
  • Titan

7+ Player Games

  • Bohnanza [gcs]
  • Carabande
  • Citadels/Ohne Furcht & Adel
  • Formula Dé
  • Pit
  • Ricochet Robot
  • Take It Easy

  • Werewolf
  • Civilization/Advanced Civ
  • Diplomacy
  • Take Six/6 Nimmt

3 Player Games

  • Big City [gcs]
  • Can't Stop
  • Carolus Magnus
  • Euphrat & Tigris
  • Puerto Rico
  • Ra
  • Samurai
  • Wer Hat Mehr? / Where's Bob's Hat?
  • Wyatt Earp

Magical Doorways

These categories are for the best games in categories relating to turning non-gamers in to gamers.

"Gateway" Games

  • Take 6/6 nimmt
  • Amazing Labyrinth
  • Cartagena
  • Elfenland
  • Get the Goods/Reibach&Co. [gcs]
  • Hare & Toroise/Hase und Igel
  • Liar's Dice/Bluff/Call My Bluff
  • Manhattan [gcs]
  • Mississippi Queen [gcs]
  • Royal Turf
  • Take It Easy
  • Transamerica
  • Union Pacific [gcs]
  • Wildlife Adventure/Expedition

S.O. (Significant Other) Games

  • Blokus
  • Bohnanza [gcs]
  • Mystery Rummy #1: Jack the Ripper
  • Mystery Rummy #3: Jekyll & Hyde
  • Schotten Totten
  • Take It Easy
  • Wyatt Earp

Kid & Adult-Friendly Games

  • Carcassonne
  • Crokinole
  • Heimlich & Co / Undercover / Top Secret Spies [gcs]
  • Honeybears
  • Midnight Party
  • Mole In The Hole
  • Pig Pile
  • Settlers of Catan [gcs]
  • Stars Wars: Epic Duels

Subjective Yumminess

These categories are for the best games in avariety of very subjective categories... prepare to disagree.

"Beautiful" Games

  • Battle Cry
  • Big City [gcs]
  • Lord of the Rings
  • Mississippi Queen [gcs]
  • Queen's Gambit
  • Starfarers of Catan

  • Die Schlacht der Dinosaurier
  • El Grande
  • Elfenroads [gcs]
  • Java
  • Krieg und Fremden
  • Ta Yü
  • Tikal

Brain-burning Games

  • Frisch Fisch/Fresh Fish
  • Bongo
  • Java
  • Roads and Boats
  • Timbuktu

Innovative Games

  • 1829/18xx
  • Carabande
  • Civilization
  • Diplomacy
  • El Grande
  • Elfenroads [gcs] /Elfenland [gcs] /Elfenlandgold [gcs]
  • Euphrat & Tigris
  • Lord of the Rings (Knizia)
  • San Marco
  • Verrater/Meuterer
  • We The People

Nastiest Games

  • Cosmic Encounter
  • Diplomacy
  • Intrige
  • Kohle, Kies & Knete
  • Manhattan [gcs]
  • Nicht die Bohne
  • Rette Sich wer Kann

  • Auf Heller und Pfennig/Kingdoms
  • Citadels/Ohne Furcht und Adel
  • Family Business
  • Illuminati
  • Junta
  • Sticheln

Strongly Themed Games

  • Battle Cry
  • Die Macher
  • Formula Dé
  • Tikal
  • Um Reifenbreite [gcs]

  • Autoscooter
  • Big City [gcs]
  • Strand Cup
  • Civilization
  • Extrablatt
  • La Citta
  • Mississippi Queen [gcs]
  • Svea Rike

The lists below will use the following format:

Name of Category

The"winning games"

Any games that missed the cut by one vote

The rest of the nominees

Games will be listed in alphabetical order, irregardless of the number of votes they received.

If more than five games are listed as "winners" in a category, it means there was a tie for the last place position. If less than five games are listed as "winners" in a category, it means that a number of the participants did not find a fifth game on the list they wanted to vote for.

The links are entries on BoardgameGeek.com unless otherwise noted. Games denoted with [gcs] have their own page on Game Central Station.

And now, without any further ado...

Designer's Best

These categories are for the best games of a particular designer.

Stefan Dorra

  • Land unter/Zum Kuckuck
  • Hick Hack in Gackelwack
  • Intrige
  • Olympia 2000 (v. Chr.)
  • Tonga Bonga
  • Volle Hütte
  • Yucata

Wolfgang Kramer (heavier games)

  • Auf Achse
  • Big Boss
  • Die Händler
  • El Caballero
  • Goldland
  • Java
  • Mexica
  • Tycoon

Wolfgang Kramer (lighter games)

  • Daytona 500 & family (Top Race, Detroit/Cleveland GP, Formel Eins, Niki Lauda) [gcs]
  • Midnight Party/Ghost Party
  • Take 6/6 nimmt!
  • Top Secret Spies/Undercover/Heimlich & Co. [gcs]
  • Viva Pamplona

  • Auf Achse
  • Columbus
  • Der Schatz des Pharaos
  • Evergreen
  • Haste Worte
  • Pepper
  • Plem Plem
  • Wildlife Adventure/Terra X/Expedition

Reiner Knizia (heavier games)

  • Lord of the Rings
  • Lost Cities
  • Stephensons Rocket
  • Traumfabrik

Reiner Knizia (lighter games)

  • Africa
  • En Garde
  • High Society
  • Quandary/Flinke Plinke
  • Royal Turf/Turf Horse Racing

[Note: probably my biggest mistake of the entire Apples Project was the ping-ponging about of Lost Cities between the lighter & heavier Knizia games categories. It should have appeared on this list, and would have handily won a place there. My mistake.]

  • Drahtseilakt
  • Formula Motor Racing
  • Honeybears
  • It's Mine!
  • Ivanhoe
  • Katzenjammer Blues
  • Money
  • Vampire
  • Zirkus Flohcati/Star Wars - Das Kartenspiel

Alan Moon

  • Das Amulett
  • Freight Train [gcs]
  • Get the Goods/Reibach&Co. [gcs]
  • Where's Bob's Hat?/Wer hat mehr?
  • Wongar

Alex Randolph

  • Code 777
  • Hol's der Geier/Raj
  • Ricochet Robot
  • Twixt

[Note: Clear information on Robert Abott's website credits Alex Randolph with the design of Code 777... so it was included here.]

  • In Teufels Küche
  • Big Shot
  • Die Osterinsel
  • Enchanted Forest/Sagaland
  • Geister/Ghosts/Die guten und die bösen Geister
  • Halunken und Spelunken
  • Inkognito
  • Square Off
  • Würmeln/Blazing Camels

Sid Sackson

  • Acquire
  • Can't Stop
  • Kohle, Kies & Knete/I'm The Boss
  • Metropolis
  • Samarkand

  • Bazaar
  • Buried Treasure/Das Superblatt
  • Business
  • Domination/Focus
  • Sleuth
  • Venture/Bosse,Die

Klaus Teuber

  • Adel verpflichtet/By Hook or by Crook
  • Barbarossa/Barbarossa und die Rätselmeister
  • Drunter & Drüber
  • Entdecker/Entdecker (new)
  • Löwenherz [gcs]
  • The Settlers of Catan (includes expansions) [gcs]

  • Der Fliegende Holländer
  • Gnadenlos
  • Settlers of Catan Card Game (includes expansions)
  • Starfarers of Catan
  • Starship Catan

Designer's Best

These categories are for the best games in a particular theme.

City Building Games

  • Big City [gcs]
  • Carcassonne
  • Chinatown
  • La Citta
  • Metropolis
  • Puerto Rico

  • Capitol
  • Citadels/Ohne Furcht & Adel
  • Drunter & Drueber
  • Manhattan [gcs]
  • Medina
  • Mexica

"D&D in A Board/Card Game" Games

[Note: This was a better category in theory than in reality... I probably should have stuck with "fantasy games", but I was being creative. Ah, well.]

  • Drakon
  • Dungeonquest
  • Heroquest/Advanced Heroquest
  • Lord of the Rings (Knizia)
  • Wiz War

  • Dragon's Gold
  • Dark Tower
  • Dungeon!
  • Magic Realm
  • Melee/Wizard
  • Tales of the Arabian Nights
  • Talisman

Economic Games (with stocks)

  • 18xx
  • Acquire
  • Santa Fe [gcs] / Santa Fe Rails
  • Stephensons Rocket
  • Stimmt So!
  • Union Pacific [gcs]

[Note: While some of the participants did not agree, it is still my contention that Attila is a stock market in barbarian drag. Enough of the folks involved agreed with me to end up including it on this list.]

  • Airlines
  • Attila
  • Big Boss
  • Palmyra
  • Shark
  • Venture

Economic Games (without stocks)

  • Chinatown
  • For Sale
  • Funkenschlag
  • Medici
  • Medieval Merchant
  • Puerto Rico

  • Auf Achse
  • Cartel
  • Die Händler
  • Empire Builder (et al)
  • Fast Food Franchise
  • Industrial Waste
  • Marracash
  • McMulti
  • Merchants of Amsterdam
  • Tycoon
  • Volldampf

Exploration Games

  • Drakon
  • El Caballero
  • Goldland
  • Nautilus
  • Starfarers of Catan
  • Starship Catan

Nautical Games

  • Atlantic Star
  • Entdecker/Entdecker (new)
  • Meuterer
  • Mississippi Queen [gcs]
  • The Settlers of Catan - Seafarers [gcs]

  • Survive!/Atlantis
  • Tonga Bonga
  • Cape Horn
  • Clippers
  • Die fliegende Hollander
  • Kapitän Wackelpudding
  • Nautilus
  • Rette sich wer Kann
  • Serenissima

Political Games

  • Die Macher
  • Diplomacy
  • Drunter & Druber
  • El Grande
  • Liberte

  • Dune
  • Europa 1945-2030
  • Illuminati
  • Junta
  • Koalition
  • Kremlin
  • Mr. President
  • San Marco

Race Games (animals: real & imaginary)

  • Ave Caesar
  • Billabong
  • Hare & Tortoise
  • Royal Turf
  • TurfMaster

  • Igel Ärgern
  • Circus Maximus
  • Crazy Race (Michael Schlacht)
  • Elchfest
  • Mush
  • The Really Nasty Horseracing Game
  • Warhamster Rally
  • Win Place & Show
  • Wurmeln/Blazing Camels

[Note: at the time of the voting, the new edition of Crazy Race themed as a train game had not yet been released.]

Race Games (cars & motorcycles)

  • Detroit-Cleveland Grand Prix [gcs]
  • Formel Fun
  • Formula Motor Racing
  • Speed Circuit
  • Stock Car Championship Racing Card Game
  • Top Race

Race Games (other)

  • Dampfross/Railway Rivals
  • Cape Horn
  • Flying Carpet/Fliegende Teppich
  • Gallop Royal
  • Montgolfiere
  • Tonga Bonga
  • Viva Pamplona
  • Von Kap bis Kairo
  • Zapp Zerapp

Rail Games

  • MetroIron Horse
  • Santa Fe/Santa Fe Rails
  • Stephensons Rocket
  • Union Pacific [gcs]
  • Volldampf

  • 18xx
  • Dampfross/Railway Rivals
  • Empire Builder/Iron Dragon/Eurorails/etc
  • Freight Train [gcs]
  • Linie 1/Streetcar [gcs]
  • Transamerica/Iron Road

Science Fiction Games

  • Cosmic Encounter
  • Dune
  • Robo Rally
  • Starfarers of Catan
  • Starship Catan

  • Merchant of Venus
  • Star Wars - The Queen's Gambit
  • 2038
  • Andromeda
  • Awful Green Things from Outer Space
  • Borderlands
  • OGRE / G.E.V
  • Outpost
  • Space Hulk
  • Star Wars - Epic Duels
  • Star Wars Episode 1 - Clash of the Lightsabers